Walk-in Showers vs. Bathtubs What Should I Install?

Picture of Written by Anton Briggs
Written by Anton Briggs

Owner of Briggs and Nins Construction

When it comes to designing or remodeling a bathroom, one of the most common questions homeowners face is whether to install a walk-in shower or a bathtub. This decision is not just about personal preference; it affects the functionality, aesthetic, and even the resale value of your home. Let’s address the common queries around each option to help you make an informed decision.

Should I install a walk-in shower or a bathtub?

If You’re Considering a Walk-in Shower

Q: Are walk-in showers better for smaller bathrooms?
A: Yes, walk-in showers can be excellent for smaller bathrooms. They typically require less space than bathtubs and can be designed to fit into various layouts, making them ideal for compact spaces.

Q: Is a walk-in shower a good choice for accessibility?
A: Absolutely. Walk-in showers are particularly beneficial for those with mobility issues or the elderly, as they eliminate the need to step over a high ledge, reducing the risk of falls.

Q: Do walk-in showers use less water than bathtubs?
A: Generally, yes. Showers tend to be more water-efficient than baths if your showers are not excessively long. This can help reduce your water bills and conserve water.

Q: What are the disadvantages of walk-in showers?
A: The main drawbacks include potentially lower resale value if you have no bathtub in the home, as some buyers prefer having at least one bathtub. Additionally, they lack the relaxation factor of a deep soak and can be costly if opting for luxurious designs or features.

If You’re Considering a Bathtub….

Q: Why might a bathtub be a better option for families?
A: Bathtubs are almost essential for families with young children. They make bathing small children easier and safer, and many kids enjoy bath time as part of their routine.

Q: Can installing a bathtub increase my home’s resale value?
A: Yes, having a bathtub can appeal to a broader audience, including families with children and those who enjoy baths, potentially boosting your home’s marketability.

Q: Are there therapeutic benefits to having a bathtub?
A: Yes, soaking in a bathtub can help relieve stress and muscle tension. Some bathtubs come with additional features like hydrotherapy jets, enhancing these therapeutic benefits.

Q: What are the cons of having a bathtub?
A: Bathtubs require more space, which can be a significant issue in smaller bathrooms. They also tend to use more water per use compared to showers, which could increase your water bill and environmental footprint. Accessibility can be another concern for people with mobility issues.

Conclusion: Which One Should I Choose?

The decision between installing a walk-in shower or a bathtub should be based on your specific needs, the space available, and who will be using the bathroom. For those with limited space or accessibility needs, a walk-in shower might be the ideal choice. However, if you have the space and your family includes young children or you enjoy baths, a bathtub could be more beneficial. In many cases, having both a walk-in shower and a bathtub in different bathrooms offers the greatest flexibility and appeal, covering all bases for functionality and resale potential.

You might also enjoy

The Benefits of Adding a Double Vanity During Your Bathroom Remodel

Are you considering a bathroom remodel and pondering whether to include a double vanity? This decision can impact not only the functionality of your bathroom but also its aesthetic appeal and resale value. Let’s explore the common questions homeowners have about adding a double vanity and why it might be a beneficial choice for your bathroom upgrade.

Current Tile Trends for Bathrooms
Current Tile Trends for Bathrooms: Choosing the Best Options

As you plan your bathroom remodel, you might be wondering about the latest trends in tile and how to choose the right options for your space. Tiling is more than just a practical inclusion; it can significantly influence the style and ambiance of your bathroom.

How to Choose the Best Contractor for Your Bathroom Remodeling Project

Choosing the right contractor for your bathroom remodel is crucial. A good contractor will bring your vision to life, while a poor choice can lead to delays, subpar work, and additional costs. Homeowners often ask, “How can I ensure I’m selecting the best contractor for the job?” Let’s delve into what you should consider to make an informed decision.

How Much Does a Bathroom Remodel Cost in 2024? Understanding The Cost Involved

When considering a bathroom remodel, one of the first questions that comes to mind is: “How much will it cost?” This is a crucial question for homeowners who need to budget appropriately and ensure they’re making wise investment decisions. Let’s dive into the details of bathroom remodeling costs to help you understand what you might expect to pay and how to prepare your budget.

The Essential Guide to Budgeting for Your Bathroom Remodel
The Essential Guide to Budgeting for Your Bathroom Remodel

Embarking on a bathroom remodel can be exciting, but before diving in, one crucial question arises: “How much will it cost?” Understanding how to effectively budget for your bathroom renovation is vital to ensure the project meets your expectations without breaking the bank. Let’s explore the key aspects of budgeting for your bathroom remodel.

Choosing the Right Basement Flooring
Choosing the Right Basement Flooring: Your Questions Answered

As you plan your basement remodel, you’re likely pondering, “What flooring should I choose?” It’s a crucial decision that affects not just the look but also the longevity and utility of your space. Basements have unique needs, particularly because they are prone to moisture. Let’s navigate through your options to find the flooring that meets your needs.

Custom Built-Ins and Features: The Key to a Truly Personalized Basement Remodel

Embarking on a basement remodel brings a common question to the
forefront: “How can I make my basement uniquely mine?” The answer
lies in custom built-ins and unique features that not only enhance the
space’s functionality but also infuse it with your personal style. Let’s
delve into the world of customizations that can turn your basement
into your favorite part of the home.

Is Adding a Bathroom to Your Basement Worth the Investment?

As you consider enhancing your home, you might wonder, “Is adding a bathroom to my basement a wise investment?” Homeowners are increasingly seeing the value in this upgrade, and we’re here to break down exactly why this could be a game-changer for your home’s functionality and value.